bigstock-Tightrope-Ideas-3402533.jpg

What should raw milk consumers do when they suspect one or more farmers of producing possibly dangerous raw milk? 

 

It’s a dilemma that faces at least some raw dairy consumers at one time or another. The big tipoff of potential danger is that the milk sours in just a few days, usually less than a week. Another clue is that cows are spending much time in muddy spring-time environs, where the mud tends to mix with manure–a potentially dangerous concoction when it comes to milk.  

 

Where am I going with this little monolog? I’m feeling my way along–I feel the same dilemma in writing this post as other raw milk consumers have felt at one time or another when they obtain raw milk they know is of questionable quality. 

 

In the last few days, I’ve heard enough from trusted sources that I feel it’s necessary to post a warning to raw milk consumers, and producers, about a potentially dangerous situation that appears to have developed at several dairies. I am intentionally avoiding getting too specific because I don’t want to provide enough information that I risk incurring the wrath of prejudiced public health regulators on innocent farmers, who are, in fact, providing a safe wholesome product. 

 

So here’s what I feel comfortable saying: Customers of a handful of dairies in the Northwest have expressed concern that the raw milk they have been obtaining in recent weeks isn’t as clean as it should be. It is souring quickly. The cows providing the milk are spending time in very muddy conditions. And some private testing has turned up disturbing results. 

 

So far, there haven’t been any illnesses that I am aware of. But everyone who has expressed concern most of all wants to avoid the possibility of another Foundation Farm tragedy. That is the Oregon raw milk dairy that saw a serious outbreak of illnesses from E.coli O157:H7 last April–19 illnesses and the hospitalization of four young children, one of whom still suffers serious effects from her illness. The individuals expressing concern say the conditions at the problem farms aren’t unlike what preceded Foundation Farm–muddy conditions for the cows, along with rapidly souring milk. 

 

The big dilemma facing everyone involved is what to do. Raw milk proponents are loathe to try to involve the public health community, because the regulators nearly universally detest raw milk in any form, along with the people who produce it or consume it. The regulators see these people as evil or crazy, or both. 

 

Yet these proponents feel the need for raw milk production standards that producers must adhere to. Layered on top of everything else, there are raw milk advocates who don’t like to discuss the safety aspects of raw milk at all, and I’m sure will have problems with what I’ve written here. 

 

The bigger problem of deciding what to authorities is a little like the situation blacks and Hispanics have long faced in trying to decide whether to alert police to possible criminal activity in their neighborhoods. Community activists are often aware of criminal activity, but often hesitate to involve police. The activists don’t know whether the police will confine their focus to the criminal activity, or whether the cops will use information to feed their warped views of the minorities and crack down on an entire neighborhood, harassing law abiders as well as troublemakers. 

 

Given the inherent dilemma in this raw milk situation, the best immediate approach is probably for consumers to exercise their own regulatory authority. Here’s some guidance on things to look for and questions to ask producers:

 

*If your raw milk is souring in six days or less, let the farmer who produced it know about the situation. Take note of the response. Does the farmer seem to welcome your feedback, or does he make excuses (it’s a seasonal thing, or “nothing to worry about–a natural process.”)?

 

*In this situation of rapidly souring milk, feel free to ask to take a look around the dairy. Once again, note the response. Ideally, you are welcomed to tour the facilities. Worst case: you are put off, and not given access to the facilities. 

 

*If the poor quality milk matches up with dirty animals and questionable facilities, express your concern to the farmer, and ask him or her to suspend sales, and warn others against drinking the milk. 

 

*Encourage any farmer with questionable milk to learn more about steps to improve sanitation. One easily accessible source is Tim Wightman’s video and booklet produced under the auspices of the Farm-to-Consumer Foundation. Another source is the Raw Milk Institute (RAWMI). These sources provide guidance on immediate steps to improve facilities sanitation, properly clean milking equipment, and properly chill milk using an ice water bath. 

 

*Inquire about what private testing the farmer is doing of the milk. Test results should show 25 or fewer coliforms and 15,000 or lower standard plate count.

 

Any farmer who resists your inquiries should be reminded that regulators are just waiting to pounce on any illnesses as an excuse to put as many farmers as possible out of business. In other words, illnesses from bad raw milk will likely mean much more serious repercussions from regulators than anything you as a diligent consumer could come up with. Much as we want regulators to change their attitudes, right now, in many places, it’s most important that consumers change their attitudes, and not accept lame excuses from farmers who are courting danger. 

**

Last stop on my brief China tour was a moving one, in Shanghai. Though Shanghai is an amazingly modern and sophisticated city of more than 20 million–hanging around in the downtown area, you could just as easily be in New York or Paris–it has a remarkable history, which includes having served as a sanctuary for Jews seeking to escape the Holocaust during the 1930s and 1940s. Yesterday I visited a small museum that commemorates the experience of some 30,000 Jews who were welcomed to Shanghai, at a time when nearly the entire world, including the United States, closed its doors to refugees. 

 

The museum is staffed by Chinese history students who offer tours of the ornate building, which includes a reconstructed synagogue, and recollections of Holocaust survivors who lived in Shanghai during the Holocaust period. One of the most prominent is former U.S. Treasury Secretary Michael Blumenthal. My wife, Jean, found her great uncle listed in a database of about 15,000 former Shanghai residents.